top of page

FEMA Chief Requests Probe into Alleged Political Bias in Hurricane Response


The White House, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

The Big Picture


FEMA Administrator Deanne Criswell has called for an independent investigation into claims that a former employee instructed personnel to avoid providing aid to homes displaying Trump campaign signs during Hurricane Helene's response. Criswell emphasized that such actions are unacceptable and reiterated her commitment to FEMA's mission of impartial service.


What Happened


  • Allegations of Bias: During federal recovery efforts for Hurricane Helene, a FEMA employee allegedly directed an 11-person team to bypass homes with visible Trump campaign signs.

  • Employee Fired: Criswell testified before the House Transportation Subcommittee, confirming that the employee responsible was terminated.


FEMA's Stance


  • Firm Rejection: Criswell condemned the orders as "completely at odds with FEMA's mission" and assured lawmakers that this behavior "will not be tolerated."

  • Corrective Actions: She noted that all bypassed residences were revisited to ensure equal aid distribution.


Investigation Calls


  • Independent Probe: Criswell pledged to request a formal investigation by the Office of Inspector General (OIG) to determine whether the incident reflects systemic issues or a one-time lapse.

  • Internal Findings: An internal review so far found no evidence implicating supervisors in directing the orders, contrary to the fired employee's claims.


Fired Employee's Claims


  • Denial of Wrongdoing: Marn’i Washington, the dismissed FEMA worker, told NewsNation she was “framed” and acted under orders, claiming, “I execute orders. I don’t create policy.”

  • Hatch Act Allegations: Washington rejected accusations of violating the Hatch Act, which prohibits political activities by federal employees.


Next Steps


  • Further Testimony: Criswell is set to address the issue before the House Oversight Committee, providing more details about FEMA's response and the potential scope of the OIG investigation.

  • Accountability Assurance: Subcommittee Chair Scott Perry (R-Pa.) pressed for transparency regarding the investigation and its scope, including any scrutiny of Washington's supervisors.


Why It Matters So Much?


This incident highlights concerns about political bias in disaster relief efforts, an area where impartiality is critical. Criswell’s firm response signals FEMA's commitment to maintaining public trust and ensuring that aid reaches all Americans, regardless of political affiliation.


Comments


bottom of page