top of page

Former Officer Found Guilty of Murder in Andre Hill Case



A jury found former police officer Adam Coy guilty of murder on Monday. He shot and killed 47-year-old Black man Andre Hill in December 2020. This verdict follows a lengthy legal battle that highlighted significant issues within police practices.


Details of the Incident


  • Shooting Context: The incident occurred on December 22, 2020, when Coy responded to a complaint about a running vehicle at approximately 1:30 a.m. He encountered Hill, who was inside an SUV.

  • Misidentified Weapon: Coy testified that he believed Hill was armed with a silver revolver. He shot Hill four times while Hill was holding a mobile phone and keys. After the shooting, Coy realized there was no weapon, stating, “I knew at that point I made a mistake.”

  • Body Camera Footage: Police body camera footage captured Hill emerging from the garage with a phone in his left hand. His right hand was not visible at the time of the shooting. Medical assistance was delayed, with nearly 10 minutes passing before officers tended to Hill, who was later pronounced dead at a hospital.


Prosecutors' Arguments


  • Compliance with Police Orders: Prosecutors argued that Hill was following Coy’s orders and posed no threat. During closing arguments, prosecutor Anthony Pierson emphasized that Hill did what he was instructed, yet still lost his life.

  • Community Impact: The case has raised broader concerns about police conduct, particularly involving unarmed Black individuals.


Reactions and Consequences


  • Sentencing Date: Adam Coy, 48, faces life in prison. A sentencing date has been set for November 25.

  • Police Chief Resignation: The shooting led to significant scrutiny of the Columbus police force. Shortly after the incident, the police chief resigned amid criticism over multiple fatal shootings involving unarmed individuals.

  • Settlement and Legislative Changes: The city of Columbus reached a $10 million settlement with Hill's family, the largest in its history. Following this, the Columbus city council enacted “Andre’s Law,” mandating that officers provide immediate medical care to injured suspects.


Summary


The conviction of Adam Coy marks a significant moment in the ongoing conversation about police accountability and the treatment of Black individuals in law enforcement encounters. As the community reflects on the implications of this case, calls for systemic changes in policing practices continue to grow.


Comentários


bottom of page